A Look At Cheap Amusements 2 Essay

This essay has a total of 1841 words and 8 pages.

A Look At Cheap Amusements 2


An extremely interesting, but ever-contradictory sociological study of sexual relationsis
presented in the Kathy Peiss book Cheap Amusements . The reason I say that it is
ever-contradictory is that the arguments are presented for both the benefit of cheap
amusements for a woman s place in society and for the reinforcement of her place. In one
breath, Peiss says that mixed-sex fun could be a source of autonomy and pleasure as well
as a cause of [a woman s] continuing oppression. The following arguments will show that,
based on the events and circumstances described in Cheap Amusements , the changes in the

ways that leisure time is spent by women has indeed benefited them in both the workplace
and at home. This position requires a closer look at specific leisure activities; where
and with whom they are spent, and the ultimate effect that these activities had on society
and gender roles. More significantly however, is how the establishment of leisure
activities for women came about, rather than the simple change in availability of such
activities. First let s look at Peiss s position on the matter of how cheap amusements
challenged gender traditions in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

What does Peiss have to say about women s roles at the turn of the century? Peiss argues
initially that young women experimented with new cultural forms in terms of sexual
expressiveness and social interaction with men, linking heterosocial culture to a sense of
modern individuality and personal style. Creating this style was an assertion of self.
Peiss

quickly discounts these assertions by saying that without economic independence, such
freedoms are hollow. Peiss s essay claims to focus on the role of working women in
fostering change from a homosocial to a heterosocial culture, but as we can see from the
earlier quote, there is still what seems to be a hint of male dominance in preventing the
experience of true leisure. By this we can see that Peiss believes women were challenging
gender norms, but doing so under the implied watchful eye of the male-dominated culture.

One very interesting point that Peiss makes is that there is now a market for leisure
time. This market included such activities as attending shows at a nickelodeon, riding the
trolley, and, especially in Manhattan, spending the day at Coney Island. What is
interesting about this point is that we must ask the following: did the market create the
desire and opportunity for leisure time or did the desire for leisure time create the
market? We must

ask this question so that we can later determine if women took initiative in establishing
their need for relaxing activities. If it is the case that women took initiative in this
area, we can safely conclude that women benefited tremendously from the changes in gender
roles as a result, because they would have subverted the so-called hollow freedoms
mentioned earlier. If the opposite is true, then it may appear as though women have
benefitted, but it

could still be argued that the male culture controlled these changes in the way the leisure market came about.
One of the more interesting aspects that Peiss mentions about the change in the
demographics of the labor force directly relates to the way leisure time is spent. Peiss
mentions many statistics that show how the working woman was quickly refusing household
work and moving to the factory or office position. More specifically, a study of 370
working mothers showed 70 percent of them to be employed in domestic and personal service
while the vast majority of their daughters worked in stores, offices, and factories (Cheap
Amusements, 39). The significance of this change lies in the resulting change in attitude
about leisure time. Now, a clearer distinction between time spent at work and

personal time could be made. Prior to this shift in the workplace, domestic workers would
catch small breaks to gossip while still caring for their employers children. Now, with
set times of arrival and departure to and from the workplace, later parts of the day are
spent in clear separation of the work environment. So again, a leisure market seems an
inevitable development.

Let s now look deeper into the particular activities newly available in this budding
leisure market and how women have subverted the current social and gender norms. For each
example of how women have subverted the norms, a contradictory argument of how norms were
reinforced will follow.

The club scene was a place where leisure activity for women sometimes challenged the
social norms of the day. The majority of the clubs were heterosexual, but there were some
that gathered only male or only female members. The clubs with only female members
sometimes generated harassment from male counterparts who were aware of such meetings. In
one instance, co-workers of female members of The Bachelor Girls Social Club taunted the
women, calling them manhaters and accusing them of celebrating Washington s Birthday
without even thinking of a man. They countered by explaining that they believe in

women s rights and they enjoy their independence and freedom. What does this reaction
say about the culture and expectations that the sexes have of each other? Let s look at
the situation in which women found themselves and then explore the implications of this
reaction. Women rarely had true leisure time, but when they did, it was spent gossiping or
resting on the doorstep with other women of the neighborhood. The men apparently expected
to always have an opportunity to share in the leisure time of a woman, no matter the
social setting. Contrary to this, woman see this male attitude as a threat to their
individuality, as expressed in the way the word freedom is used in their

reply to their male co-workers. So by simply arranging for an all female social club,
women challenged the notion that their leisure time should not be autonomous, but spent
with men.

At the same time, other social clubs of heterosocial emphasis were re-enforcing the
Continues for 4 more pages >>