Compare and Constrast Essay on A Separate Peace

This essay has a total of 2654 words and 8 pages.

A Separate Peace

A Separate Peace
By: Anonymous
E-mail: intrepidhp@home.com

A Separate Peace A Separate Peace is a novel by John Knowles that is about prep school
experiences during World War II. This book was a good story about an adolescents attempt
to understand the world and himself. I enjoyed reading about Gene's journey towards
maturity and the adult world. This book takes place in Devon School, New Hampshire during
a summer session when Gene Forrester was sixteen years old. One day Gene and Finny, his
friend and roommate, went to a large tree by the river. Finny suggested that they try and
jump from the tree into the river below them. This jump was usually for older boys. But
they both made the jump successfully, and Finny formed the Summer Suicide Society, which
is dedicated to members being initiated by jumping from the tree to the river. Each time,
Gene and Finny must go first, but Gene always has a fear of jumping. Finny always was
considered the best athlete in school, and Gene tried to counterbalance by being the best
student. After a while of joining Finny's activities, Gene thinks that Finny is
intentionally trying to make him fail out of school. He starts to dislike Finny and his
activities, and Gene starts interrupting his schoolwork to jump from the tree more and
more often. On one occasion, he thoughtlessly jounces the limb and Finny falls and breaks
his leg. Finny's leg is so shattered that he will not be able to play sports again. Gene
is scared that Finny will tell that he intentionally pushed him off the tree. After his
first visit to the infirmary, Gene realizes that Finny trusts Gene completely and would
never accuse Gene. After summer vacation was over, Gene guilty conscience decides to
confess to Finny that he had deliberately pushed him out of the tree. Finny refuses to
believe his confession, and demands that Gene leave. Autumn session had started and Gene
did not try to go out for any sports. Students volunteered to do jobs left from the
workers that were sent off to war. Many students enlisted into the army, and Gene was
going to do the same until one day he returns to his room and Finny was there. Finny
confronts Gene and tells him that he is going to coach him for the 1944 Olympics. Gene
explains that sports are not important while the war is going on. Finny will not believe
in the war, and feels that he has suffered so much already. Gene is drawn into this belief
of peace with Finny, and is not in touch with the reality that is going on. Gene's good
friend Leper was the first to enlist in the war, which made the war seem more and more
unreal since Leper had never been concerned about anything. Leper left after the recruiter
came to Devon and showed pictures of the ski troops in action. Later, Gene gets a
telegraph from Leper asking for help, and asks Gene to come at once. Gene arrives at
Leper's house, Gene tries to humor Leper with jokes, but notices that Leper is too nervous
and disturbed. Gene asks him how long he will be home, and Leper says that he has escaped
the war. Then Leper gets mad and accuses Gene of thinking of him as not normal. Leper and
Gene fight over new army words and Leper says that Gene will soon be trapped. Leper
reminds Gene of the time he knocked Finny out of the tree. Gene becomes outraged and calls
Lepur a "crazy bastard." Then Leper switches moods and begins laughing at the fact that
Finny is crippled for life. Gene knocks Leper over in his chair and onto the floor, and
his mom comes in and tells Gene that Leper is ill. Gene tries to leave, but Leper makes
him stay for lunch. Gene feels ashamed to accept the invitation for lunch. Back to Finny's
fall, some boys from the dormitory come to get Gene and Finny to take them to the assembly
hall. They begin asking questions about Finny's broken leg, Finny refuses to answer the
questions and bursts out of the room and falls down the stairs and breaks the same leg
again. Gene tries to visit Finny in the infirmary but Finny wants nothing to do with him.
The following day, Finny wants to know why he pushed him out of the tree. Gene says that
it was a blind impulse. That same day, while the doctor is resetting Finny's leg, some
marrow gets into his bloodstream and Finny dies instantly. Gene does not cry about his
death, and feels that he died with Finny and that he shouldn't cry over one's own death.
Gene later comes to the conclusion that war never meant anything to him, that he had
fought his own war and had killed his enemy at school. The major conflict in the story is
between Gene and Finny. Gene is jealous of Finny because is the best athlete at school and
tries to compete with that by being the best student. Eventually, Gene's jealousy causes
him to jounce the limb while Finny jumps. Gene then becomes aware of his inner self and
learns of his true feelings. He realizes that Finny has no hatred or jealously towards
him. Another conflict is between Leper and Gene. When Leper decided to enlist in the army,
it made Gene think that the war was unreal because Leper was not really in touch with
reality. When Gene went to go visit him at his house, they got into a verbal argument, and
went off on each other. Leper keeps saying that he has escaped from the war, and Gene
doesn't understand what he means by it. Gene is really infuriated with Leper when he
blames Gene at the meeting and causes Finny to fall down the stairs, and die. The mock
trial, or assembly, was the climax of the story. It was called by some of the boys at
Devon. At the meeting, they tried to get down to what really happened on the tree the day
that Finny fell and broke his leg. Fingers started to point at Gene, and Finny could not
answer any questions. Finny angrily left the assembly and fell down the stairs, braking
the same leg again. While in the process of resetting his knee, some marrow got into his
bloodstream and he died. The theme of this novel is Man's Inhumanity to Man. There is a
strong relation of this in this novel. The first point is about Finny's tragic fall and
how Gene was the cause of it. Support from the story is Finny's desire to jump from the
tree. Gene said that he was coming to join him but Finny reminded him about studying.
Gene's thoughts on the matter were, "He had never been jealous of me for a second. Now I
knew that there never was and never could have been any rivalry between us, I couldn't
stand this." The second support is Gene's actions leading to the accident. He took a step
toward the trunk, put his knees and jounced the limb. Thus, Finny lost his balance and
tumbled to the ground. The third support goes back to the scene of the accident after Gene
watches Finny fall. And he thinks to himself, "It was the first clumsy physical action I
had ever seen him make." More less, this is a sign of pride within Gene as he watches the
good athlete, Finny fall out of the tree. The second point is on the scene where Brinker
brings Finny and Gene to the mock trial to let everyone know the real truth about the
cause of the accident. In other words, it was a way of blasting away Gene and shoving his
reputation as a respected individual into the ground. Support from the story is when
Brinker and three acquaintances come into Gene and Finny's dorm and pull them out. After
they entered the Assembly Room, Brinker remarks, "You see how Finny limps." This phrase
Continues for 4 more pages >>