Gender roles Argumentative Essay

This essay has a total of 1592 words and 6 pages.

gender roles


Since the beginning of time men have played the dominant role in nearly every culture
around the world. If the men were not dominant, then the women and men in the culture were
equal. Never has a culture been found where women have dominated. In "Society and Sex
Roles" by Ernestine Friedl, Friedl supports the previous statement and suggests that
"although the degree of masculine authority may vary from one group to the next, males
always have more power" (261). Friedl discusses a variety of diverse conditions that
determine different degrees of male dominance focusing mainly on the distribution of
resources. In The Forest People by Colin Turnbull, Turnbull describes the culture of the
BaMbuti while incorporating the evident sex roles among these "people of the forest". I
believe that the sex roles of the BaMbuti depicted by Turnbull definitely follow the
pattern that is the basis of Freidl's arguments about the conditions that determine
variations of male dominance. Through examples of different accounts of sex roles of the
BaMbuti and by direct quotations made by Turnbull as well as members of the BaMbuti tribe,
I intend on describing exactly how the sex roles of the BaMbuti follow the patterns
discussed by Freidl. I also aim to depict how although women are a vital part of the
BaMbuti culture and attain equality in many areas of the culture, men still obtain a
certain degree of dominance.

Friedl argues that "the source of male power among hunter-gatherers lies in their control
of a scarce, hard to acquire, but necessary nutrient-animal protein" (263). This is proven
by the people of the BaMbuti since they do in fact rely on the hunter-gatherer method
which is a process where the people depend on wild plants and animals for subsistence.
Although the women of the BaMbuti culture contribute a substantial amount to the hunting
process by foraging for mushrooms and nuts and by driving the animals into the net, the
men actually kill the animal and distribute it among the tribe. Turnbull states that
"survival can be achieved only by the closest co-operation and by an elaborate system of
reciprocal obligations which insures that everyone has some share in the day's catch"
(107). According to Friedl this distribution obligates others to the hunter and "these
obligations constitute a form of power or control over others, both men and women" (264).
Friedl informs us that hunter-gatherer societies fit into four basic types, one of which
is where "men and women work together in communal hunts and as teams gathering edible
plants", as did the members of the BaMbuti (265). Turnbull states that "for the net
hunters it is impossible to hunt alone. Men, women and children all have to co-operate if
the hunt is to be successful" (97). Therefore the BaMbuti do operate somewhat on an
egalitarian basis yet the distribution of protein from the male hunters gives them a
certain amount of power since the meat is the people's primary source of food. Friedl
expresses how the opinions of hunters in a culture play an important part in many
decisions made in within the group. For example, the male hunters of the BaMbuti always
make the decision of moving the camp to a different location although the women may give
their opinion. In reference to a decision to return to the forest Turnbull states that
"Njobo, the great elephant hunter, had the final say" (50). Friedl also states that
although there is a "pattern of some degree of male dominance among foragers, most of
these societies are egalitarian" since "foragers, as a rule, do not like to give or take
orders, and assume leadership only with reluctance" (267-268). This is shown in The Forest
People when Turnbull states that "Pygmies dislike and avoid personal authority" and that
"everything settles itself with apparent lack of organization. Co-operation is the key to
Pygmy society; you can expect it and you can demand it, and you have to give it"
(124-125). The equalities and inequalities are not only seen in the process of the hunt
but also in the consistent patterns and actions that take place within the camp when the
hunt is not taking place.

Friedl also describes other conditions that determine the degree of male dominance and
variability in a culture. She explains how in some cultures women have a great deal of
freedom whereas in others, women are abused and treated as objects. She also shows a
degree of inequality by emphasizing the domestic chores women are expected to do in many
cultures. Friedl states that in some cultures "when a man returns from a hunting trip, the
woman, no matter what she is doing, hurries home and quietly but rapidly prepares a meal
for her husband. Should the wife be slow in doing this, the husband is within his rights
to beat her" (262). This sense of this obligation for women to tend to all the domestic
chores such as cooking, tending to the hut, and caring for the children is shown numerous
times throughout The Forest People. Although Turnbull seems to reiterate the apparent
equality between the women and men in the BaMbuti tribe, many of the roles played by women
and statements made by the men of the BaMbuti prove otherwise. Kenge, a bachelor of the
BaMbuti, was forced to fix his own roof on his hut and stated that "it was always like
Continues for 3 more pages >>




  • The forest people
    the forest people In his book, The Forest People, Colin Turnbull achieves the taste and feel of life inside a Mbuti community, but in doing so offers a skewed anthropological look at the peoples of the African Congo. When reading the book, I did truly feel a part of the Mbuti world, but I also noticed a lack of anthropological accuracy when it came to portraying effect had on Pygmies by the lives and cultures of surrounding natives. Not only does Turnbull lack respect non-Pygmy culture, but he a
  • Are they worth it
    Are they worth it "Children of the Forest" By Ryan Willis Anth 1200 Sect.007 Mar.9, 1999 "Children of the Forest" is a narrative written by Kevin Duffy. This book is a written testament of an anthropologist’s everyday dealings with an African tribe by the name of the Mbuti Pygmies. My purpose in this paper is to inform the reader of Kevin Duffy’s findings while in the Ituri rainforest. Kevin Duffy is one of the first and only scientists to have ever been in close contact with the Mbuti. If an Mb
  • Children of the Forest
    Children of the Forest Sect.007 Mar.9, 1999 "Children of the Forest" is a narrative written by Kevin Duffy. This book is a written testament of an anthropologist\'s everyday dealings with an African tribe by the name of the Mbuti Pygmies. My purpose in this paper is to inform the reader of Kevin Duffy\'s findings while in the Ituri rainforest. Kevin Duffy is one of the first and only scientists to have ever been in close contact with the Mbuti. If an Mbuti tribesman does not want to be found, t
  • Dynamics of founder effect
    dynamics of founder effect An Introduction Into the Dynamics of the Founder Effect By: John Philip The Human Species MWF 3:00 p.m. Populations are divided by geographic boundaries, confining a specific region/group of people to share and distribute its genetic traits within themselves without outward influence. The size of these populations is dependant upon whether certain mountains, rivers, deserts, oceans, or other extreme geographical, cultural, or technological conditions determine the ten
  • Mbuti
    Mbuti Children of the Forest Sect.007 Mar.9, 1999 "Children of the Forest" is a narrative written by Kevin Duffy. This book is a written testament of an anthropologist\'s everyday dealings with an African tribe by the name of the Mbuti Pygmies. My purpose in this paper is to inform the reader of Kevin Duffy\'s findings while in the Ituri rainforest. Kevin Duffy is one of the first and only scientists to have ever been in close contact with the Mbuti. If an Mbuti tribesman does not want to be fo
  • Black Reconstruction
    Black Reconstruction Black Reconstruction An analysis of Black Identity, Politics, and Religion Prior to the Civil War and Reconstruction, the main goal of the African American population was to be granted freedom. African Americans had been enslaved since 1619 in America, when the first slaves were sold on the auction block. However, their concepts of freedom were extremely romanticized and highly unrealistic as a direct result of the atrocities they witnessed and endured in the institution of
  • Rwanda Report
    Rwanda Report Rwanda Report Rwanda is an African country in East Central Africa. Rwanda is just a very little degrees below the Equator which is not too shabby in my mind. Below the Equator would be in the south and so it is actually in south central. Get it South Central (get it)HA!HA! In Rwanda there are about seven hundred and ten per square which in my mind a whole lot of people I don\'t think even San Bernardino has that many but what do I know. Rwanda is twenty six thousand three hundred a