The impact of postmodernism on the What is History Essay

This essay has a total of 3230 words and 16 pages.

The impact of postmodernism on the What is History? debate


To explain the impacts of postmodernism, we have to understand the very composite nature
of postmodernism, which is a relatively new all encompassing philosophy and one that
reputedly lacks a historiography. The nature of the title question is very philosophical
to which an equally philosophical answer could be given - why? However I am not so bold as
to give that as the answer. I will therefore endeavour to simplify and qualify, what I
consider are, related factors and, where applicable, their origins. Similarly, as the
title requests, I will also tackle their relationship with the ‘what is history?' debate
(having first explained exactly what it is) to offer a conclusion as to the profundity of
their impact.


The debate that continues through modern day historians on exactly ‘what is history?'
was instigated by the writings of Collingwood, Elton and Carr, during the 20th century. It
appears a very multifaceted issue and seldom does a historian writing about the ongoing
debate fully agree with any of his cohorts in any of the intellectual disciplines.


In the words of Oscar Wilde, ‘To write history we have to rewrite history'. Obviously,
this always involves revision, which encompasses ‘our understanding of the past and our
sense of the persistence of the past into the present.' (1) Once again, it is a complex
issue to address as each individual may offer a different perspective, on their view of
past histories due to personal circumstance and ideology, which subsequently ‘emphasises
the connections between different fields of human endeavour.'(2)


There is commonly a distinction between history and sociology in as much as history
commonly refers to study of past events and human affairs, while sociology may be defined
as ‘the study of human society, with an emphasis on generalisations about its structure
and development.'(3) Rather than to get engaged in the parochial debate between how
history and sociology differ, it is much easier to accept that they compliment each other.
In fact there are a number of intellectual disciplines (including social anthropology,
geography, politics and economics, to name but a few), which are all complimentary to the
writing of history.



Clearly the more recent the event, the more likely we will have more evidence as
contemporary sources whether they be oral accounts, manuscripts, diaries and so forth have
had less time to withstand the destructive processes, experienced by many other similar
sources, throughout the passage of time. However, this is not to dismiss findings from
archaeological digs, as with the help from modern technology it is believed we can
interpret quite accurately dates, scenes and lifestyles of societies from long past
epochs.

With regard to the impact of postmodernism on the history debate we need to understand the
meanings of both modernism and postmodernism. The former is the philosophy that began with
the enlightenment during the 17th and 18th centuries in which science and art flourished.

Rene Descartes (born in 1596) is perhaps the single most important philosopher of the
European Enlightenment, the period in which philosophy emphasised reason and individualism
rather than accepted tradition. Having studied under the Jesuits, who stressed the
importance of the method of acquiring knowledge over everything else, Descartes developed
a life-long obsession with how knowledge was acquired rather than the substance of
knowledge itself. He deliberated over the basic principles of philosophy by asking the
questions and reasoning with the answers to ‘How do we know things to be true and how do
we distinguish the false from the true?'(4) Initially he stopped believing in everything
but later realised that this was practically impossible and therefore set up a provision
of rules to adhere to. Summarised by Hooker (1996), Descartes believed that ‘if you
can't be sure that anything is true, then you should accept for the time being what the
people around you believe, especially in the field of morals. Once you arrive at
certainty, then you can reject what other people say is true, but until then, you need
some system of knowledge and morality to live by.'(5)







In his bid to find a common truth he realised the most simple of notions; the fact that he
possessed the ability to think proved that he existed. He is renowned for his quote,
"Cogito, ergo sum" which translates as "I think, therefore I am." Hooker (1996) suggests
that ‘the importance of the cogito is that it privileges the individual over tradition
(Descartes is explicitly rejecting tradition) and privileges the individual's perception
of the truth over some objective truth or some commonly shared truth.'(6) This basically
means that the individual's subjective experience is the foundation of truth. However, the
fact that only one viewpoint can generally be accepted poses many problems, as often there
are no absolute truths.


The following traditional parable offers an example of the problems associated with the
belief that an individual's subjective experience may offer the foundation of truth:


An elephant was brought to a group of blind men who had never encountered such an animal
before. One felt a leg and reported that an elephant is a great living pillar. Another
felt the trunk and reported that an elephant is a great snake. Another felt a tusk and
reported that an elephant is like a sharp ploughshare. And so on. And then they all
quarrelled together, each claiming that his account was the truth and therefore all the
others false.

(Cited from Kierkegaard, 1995)

Although the accounts offered by each of the blind men are viewpoints, they cannot be
considered as absolute truths nor can they be dismissed as false. Kierkegaard (1995),
suggests that an absolute truth, or one that is true for all, ‘cannot be achieved
because of the constant motion of circumstances of who said it, to whom, when, where, why,
and how it was said.'(7) However, it is generally recognised that if the blind men had
accepted the different truths and every perception of the elephant had been taken into
consideration, then quite obviously opinions may have changed and adapted.



The post-modernist belief accepts that there is no governing absolute truth when trying to
define or interpret reality and morality. What Bentley (1999) described as, ‘the
shortest known definition of postmodernist assumption,'(8) was offered by Lyotard as a
‘disbelief in meta narratives' of western culture, in his book entitled, The Post Modern
Condition, in 1984. Lyotard argues that one of the difficulties associated with meta
narratives is that only one perspective is offered - even when it may make sense to view a
situation from a number of different angles. This basically means that our traditional
methods of knowledge and practice through means of religion (Christianity), science,
democracy or communism and progress, no longer exist in an unquestioning realm.


Evidently one could argue that from the ‘what is history?' question rises a very
contentious debate, not only due to the complexity of history per se but also due to the
perspective and interpretation of the individual who is addressing the question. For
simplicity, an answer to what history is could be obtained from the Concise Oxford
Dictionary, one that reads; ‘the total accumulation of past events especially relating
to human affairs or to the accumulation of developments connected to a particular nation,
person, thing etc.'(9) However, for the purpose of this essay I will now address the
various ways in which history has been addressed and interpreted.


The apparent condemnation, by Lyotard, of ‘authorised versions' of history potentially
undermines (even) the works undertaken by the 19th century historian Leopold von Ranke,
who was famous for his political "world history," as he endeavoured to show it "how it
really was." This claim to write down what actually happened ‘fell victim to what
anthropologists have recently termed the ‘myth of realism,' in our so-called post-modern
era.' (10) In essence, this refers to the determined boundaries between fact and fiction,
established by historians to date, being eroded by postmodernists.







The scientific method of writing history, presented by Ranke, continued throughout the
19th century. The political adaptations of history favoured by other such historians of
the period, were described by Butterworth as predominantly ‘Protestant, progressive and
Whig,' as he considered that they praised revolutions providing that they had been
successful which invariably produced ‘a story of which is the ratification if not the
glorification of the present.'(11) As a religious outsider, in as much, as he was a
Methodist, he was also a Cambridge don of history. He wrote a book entitled ‘The Whig
interpretation of history' (in 1931) which also popularised the term. Once again, he
strongly believed that ‘Whig history studied the past with reference to the present' and
argued that historians should ‘study the past for its own sake instead of using it to
justify the present.' (12)

It could be argued that even though we have distanced ourselves from such ‘traditional'
methods of learning and our subsequent understanding or accepting attitudes, associated
with the 18th and early 19th centuries (discussed earlier on page 4), they were the basis
from which we have progressed. As early as 1907, Lord Acton (professor of Modern history
at Cambridge) accepted that ‘Ultimate history we cannot have in this generation; but we
can dispose of conventional history, and show the point we have reached on the road from
one to another, now that all information is within reach, and every problem has become
capable of solution.'(13) Basically, it appears that historians like Acton believed that
they had compiled the corpus of material required in a bid for future generations to
discover the truth.

Having briefly mentioned in passing objectivity and subjectivity with regard to Descartes'
philosophy, it would be fair to offer a basic denotation of their individual meanings.
Elton and Carr basically shared the belief that history amounts to the search for truth.
However they established a division of two principle theories on ‘what is history?' in
their respective objective and subjective approaches.


It is commonly a shared belief among historians that reputable historians recognise ‘the
need for a sense of objectivity and impartiality,'(14) and condemn those who fail to
adhere to the critical standards and methods used (perhaps the lack of diversity of
sources or the usage of completely biased accounts). Elton sought to achieve an
approximation of truth and appreciated that just as future adjustments were to be expected
it remained an objective fact. The assimilation between Von Ranke and Elton is evident in
Continues for 8 more pages >>




  • Captain Swing
    Captain Swing Captain Swing is an enjoyable collaboration between E. J. Hobsbawm and George Rude that depicts the social history of the English agricultural wage-laborers uprising of 1830. According to Hobsbawm and Rude, historiography of the laborers rising of 1830 is negligible. Most of what is known by the general public comes from J. L. And Barbara Hammonds The Village Laborer published in 1911. They consider this an exceedingly valuable work, but state that the Hammonds oversimplified ev
  • A HISTORIOGRAPHY OF
    A HISTORIOGRAPHY OF A HISTORIOGRAPHY OF ROGER SHERMAN LOOMIS The tales of the Arthurian legend are some of the most popular from medieval times, and the reason for this is primarily due to their fabulous nature. In them are the exploits of heroes and the machinations of villains, the workings of sorcerers and the existence of magical objects. They embody the noble themes of chivalry and sacrifice, as well as those of revenge and evil. Action, violence, and sex are all included, and as shall be s
  • Provisional Government
    Provisional Government This so-called October Revolution was an "armed insurrection" carried out by the Bolshevik Party using the apparatus of the Petrograd Soviet. Lenin insisted that the transfer of power from the Provisional Government to the Bolsheviks take this militarized form rather than the political form of a vote by the forthcoming All-Russian Congress of Soviets, an approach favored by Zinoviev and Kamenev. Lenin did this because he believed, as did Marx, that the class struggle was c
  • Role of AfroCubans in the War of Independence
    Role of AfroCubans in the War of Independence What distinguished the final War of Independence (1895-1898) from the earlier Ten Years\' War (1868-1878) and the short-lived Guerra Chiquita (1879-1880) was the war\'s success throughout the majority of the island, the final ousting of the Spanish through the American intervention, the espousal of an egalitarian ideology by a radical multiracial military leadership, and the iconization of the war\'s two most revered heroes: Jos Mart and Antonio Ma
  • The French Revolutinary Wars
    The French Revolutinary Wars THE FRENCH REVOLUTIONARY WARS: 1787-1802 The French Revolutionary Wars: 1787-1802, by T. C. W. Blanning, is a super Work of historiography. Far more ambitious than its modest title suggests, it is the history of the French Revolution as well as a military and diplomatic history of Europe from 1787 to 1802. Blanning enriches our understanding of the Revolution by placing it in its European context, by showing how it affected and was affected by France\'s neighbors. He
  • Science4
    science4 Forty years ago the British historian Herbert Butterfield proclaimed that the \'so called \'scientific revolution,\' popularly associated with the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries... outshines everything since the rise of Christianity and reduces the Renaissance and Reformation to the rank of mere episodes, mere internal displacements, within the system of medieval Christendom.\' It was a remarkable claim. But in the generation following Butterfield\'s classic survey, The Origins of
  • Progressive Historians
    Progressive Historians One must decide the meaning of progressive historiography. It can mean either the history written by progressive historians, or it can mean history written by historians of the Progressive era of American history and shortly after. The focus that was chosen for this paper is more in keeping with the latter interpretation, if for no other reason than it provides a useful compare-and-contrast control literature. The caveat is this: the focus of this report is on the pr
  • Sam johnson
    sam johnson Samuel Johnson Born: September 18, 1709 in Lichfield, Staffordshire, England Died: December 13, 1784 in Bolt Court, England Nationality: British Occupation: Poet, Playwright, Journalist, Essayist, Critic Source: Concise Dictionary of British Literary Biography, Volume 2: Writers of the Restoration and Eighteenth Century, 1660-1789. Gale Research, 1992. Table of Contents Biographical Essay Further Readings Works Although Johnson\'s output of writing was enormous, only a relatively sm
  • Chinese art During the Early Empire
    Chinese art During the Early Empire In this essay, I will look at the outpouring of thought, art and literature during the early empire. More so though, I will focus on what factors led to this renewed focus on culture in the early empire. It would seem that there were several factor which would lead to this renewed interest in culture in early China, but the most significant of these factors would be the re-establishment of a strong central government. This re-establishment of a strong central
  • October Revolution
    October Revolution 6/12/98 THE OCTOBER REVOLUTION, THE PEOPLES REVOLUTION The October Revolution was no more than a well planned military coup carried out with out the knowledge and against the wishes of the people. This statement is entirely false, the October Revolution was wished for and very necessary for the people of Russia, to bring more power back to the people. The events of 1917 were crucial for the Bolsheviks, they represented their rise in power and their rise in popularity with t
  • What is history
    what is history What is History? The definition of history, is a question which has sparked international debate for centuries between the writers, readers, and the makers of history. In the words of acclaimed historian Edward Gibbon, "History is indeed little more than the register of the crimes, follies and misfortunes of mankind." A more romantic view on the subject was taken by Cicero. He said, "History is the witness that testifies the passing of time. It illuminates reality, vitalizes mem
  • WW II
    WW II Journal of Social History Summer, 1999 The World Within War: America\'s Combat Experience in World War II.(Review) Author/s: Michael Neiberg By Gerald F. Linderman (New York: The Free Press, 1997. viii plus 408pp.). More than 16,000,000 Americans served in the Armed Forces during World War U, but only 800,00 (or just 5%) took part in what Gerald Linderman calls "extended combat." (1) Their world, he convincingly argues, differed so fundamentally from the world of non-combat soldiers that
  • Book Review
    Book Review In his book Contesting Castro: The United States and the Triumph of the Cuban, Thomas G. Patterson explores Cuban relationships with the United States during the Batista and Castro regimes. In the 1950s, when Fulgencio Batista was in power, the United States had an almost imperialistic dominance over Cuba. Patterson uses the word Hegemony to describe this dominance. He defines hegemony as the dominance or preponderant influence that permitted U.S. decisions to condition Cubas p
  • Pachewychewy chomp
    pachewychewy chomp Progressive Historians By: Bambi One must decide the meaning of progressive historiography. It can mean either the history written by progressive historians, or it can mean history written by historians of the Progressive era of American history and shortly after. The focus that was chosen for this paper is more in keeping with the latter interpretation, if for no other reason than it provides a useful compare-and-contrast control literature. The caveat is this: the foc
  • Pride and Prejudice4
    Pride and Prejudice4 In Jane Austen\'s time, there was no real way for young women of the "genteel" classes to strike out on their own or be independent. Professions, the universities, politics, etc. were not open to women (thus Elizabeth\'s opinion "that though this great lady [Lady Catherine] was not in the commission of the peace for the county, she was a most active magistrate in her own parish" is ironic, since of course no woman could be a justice of the peace or magistrate). Few occupati
  • Greek Philosophy
    Greek Philosophy Greek Philosophy Philosophy, the use of reason and argument in seeking truth and knowledge of reality. Throughout history man has searched for the origins of his existence, both on an outward and inward level, seeking truth and understanding of his world. The first culture to actively explore this idea of philosophy was the Greeks. Because their civilization placed less emphasis on religion and the masses didn\'t have to constantly answer to religious figures man had time to ex
  • What is history
    what is history What is History? The definition of history, is a question which has sparked international debate for centuries between the writers, readers, and the makers of history. In the words of acclaimed historian Edward Gibbon, "History is indeed little more than the register of the crimes, follies and misfortunes of mankind." A more romantic view on the subject was taken by Cicero. He said, "History is the witness that testifies the passing of time. It illuminates reality, vitalizes mem
  • Comparitive Flood Stories
    Comparitive Flood Stories Most comparisons between Genesis and ancient Creation or Flood stories can be classified as comparative religious studies. They generally involve one text isolated from its original historical context (e.g., the Babylonian creation myth Enuma Elish or the Flood tablet of the Gilgamesh Epic) and one related biblical narrative. On the basis of currently available evidence, their earliest-known written form can be dated only to the first half of the first millenium B.C. W
  • Captain Swing
    Captain Swing Hobsbawm, E. J. and Rude, George (1975) Captain Swing. New York, NY: W.W. Norton and Company, Inc., 384 pp. Captain Swing is an enjoyable collaboration between E. J. Hobsbawm and George Rude that depicts the social history of the English agricultural wage-laborers\' uprising of 1830. According to Hobsbawm and Rude, historiography of the laborers\' rising of 1830 is negligible. Most of what is known by the general public comes from J. L. And Barbara Hammond\'s The Village Laborer pu
  • My Friend Hamilton -Who I shot
    My Friend Hamilton -Who I shot "My Friend Hamilton—Whom I Shot" A Historiographical Discussion of the Duel Between Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton Steven C. Smith Phi Alpha Theta Ohio Regional Conference Ohio Northern University 3 April 2004 The duel between Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton holds a significant relevance in American history and should be examined within the context of early American culture and politics. The recent historiography of the incident provides us with a complex, e
  • Feminism in Jane Austen
    Feminism in Jane Austen Feminism in Jane Austen I often wonder how you can find time for what you do, in addition to the care of the house; and how good Mrs. West could have written such books and collected so many hard works, with all her family cares, is still more a matter of astonishment! Composition seems to me impossible with a head full of joints of mutton and doses of rhubarb. -- Jane Austen, letter of September 8 1816 to Cassandra I will only add in justice to men, that though to the la
  • History Guidelines
    History Guidelines When you read an elementary or high school history book you get the same general idea. In 1492 Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue. These books have to follow the standards called National History Guidelines. Should we change these guidelines to reveal the not so hidden facts about history? This topic is very controversial. There are many reasons why and why not we should teach by the History Guidelines. Using them means controlling children\'s minds, however without th
  • The impact of postmodernism on the What is History
    The impact of postmodernism on the What is History? debate To explain the impacts of postmodernism, we have to understand the very composite nature of postmodernism, which is a relatively new all encompassing philosophy and one that reputedly lacks a historiography. The nature of the title question is very philosophical to which an equally philosophical answer could be given - why? However I am not so bold as to give that as the answer. I will therefore endeavour to simplify and qualify, what I
  • Irish Migration to Quebec
    Irish Migration to Quebec From the time that people began living in groups, people have migrated to suit their personal needs. For some, it was to escape difficult times or hardships faced by their ethnic group. Such is the case of the Irish who migrated to Quebec from 1815 to the Potato Famine of 1847. What causes and factors drove these people to cross an ocean and leave their homeland for the unknown prospects of Quebec? To examine and fully answer this question, one must look at the social,
  • Germany under Bismarck
    Germany under Bismarck Germany under Bismarck The Historical Debate The view of Bismarck over the years has changed and it is the historical debate surrounding our perception of him and his intentions that often shapes our interpretation of the German unification. No 19th century figure has attracted the attention and controversy that surround the achievement of Otto von Bismarck, with the exception perhaps of Napoleon Bonaparte. The success of Bismarck\'s work in unifying Germany has shifted fr
  • Metternich The Leader
    Metternich The Leader Prince Klemens von Metternich: His Ideology, his Role in History, and the Stories we Tell. Metternich was an extremely intelligent man who turned his conservative beliefs into international policy. Metternich was a confident leader who put little faith in popular opinion or sentiment because he believed that the common man was too fickle in his loyalties and too inept to understand the magnitude of foreign policy. He was a loyal servant to the Austrian Emperor, even though
  • Progressive Historians
    Progressive Historians One must decide the meaning of progressive historiography. It can mean either the history written by progressive historians, or it can mean history written by historians of the Progressive era of American history and shortly after. The focus that was chosen for this paper is more in keeping with the latter interpretation, if for no other reason than it provides a useful compare-and-contrast control literature. The caveat is this: the focus of this report is on the predomin
  • The Reliability of the Bible
    The Reliability of the Bible The Reliability of the Bible By Jimmy Kinnaird I think that every argument that we may have come at us who believe in Christ finds itself, in the end, attacking the reliability of the Bible. Other religions have their books of authority. How do they stack up to the Bible? I just had a conversation with a certain Elder Robinson. He is a Mormon missionary from Idaho Falls, Idaho. I was up in his hometown two years ago doing what he is trying to accomplish here in Oklah
  • Captain Swing
    Captain Swing Hobsbawm, E. J. and Rude, George (1975) Captain Swing. New York, NY: W.W. Norton and Company, Inc., 384 pp. Captain Swing is an enjoyable collaboration between E. J. Hobsbawm and George Rude that depicts the social history of the English agricultural wage-laborers\' uprising of 1830. According to Hobsbawm and Rude, historiography of the laborers\' rising of 1830 is negligible. Most of what is known by the general public comes from J. L. And Barbara Hammond\'s The Village Laborer pu
  • Desegregation historiography
    desegregation historiography Equality and equal opportunity are two terms that have changed or have been redefined over the last 100 years in America. The fathers of our constitution wanted to establish justice and secure liberty for the people of the United States. They wrote about freedom and equality for men, but historically it has not been practiced. In the twentieth century large steps have been made to make the United States practice the ideals declared in the Constitution and Bill of Rig
  • History of Paper
    History of Paper The first historical mention of paper is 104 A.D. in China. The Empress of China at that time loved books and wanted to have a lot of them made. At the time everything was written on silk scrolls which were extremely expensive and time consuming to make. She wanted something cheaper and easier to use and so she asked one of her servants, a gentleman by the name of Tsi Lun to come up with an alternative. He worked for over nine years experimenting with different things and finall
  • Machines: Are They Helpful Or Too Much Trouble?
    Machines: Are They Helpful Or Too Much Trouble? Machines: Are They Helpful Or Too Much Trouble? The historiography and various phases of the Industrial Revolution were very important. Population increase and the expansion of capital, credit and commerce were one of the phases. The role of entrepreneurs, workers and inventions in boosting production were another phase. Textiles, coal, transport and public services started becoming of value to people. The social consequences included women and chi
  • Revelation
    Revelation Revelation, n. A famous book in which St. John the Divine concealed all that he knew. The revealing is done by the commentators, who know nothing. 1 The book of Revelation, the only apocalypse among the twenty-seven books of the New Testament, has always occupied a marginal role within the field of Biblical interpretation. Its bizarre visions of beasts, dragons, plagues, and cataclysms have inspired poets and artists while confounding more traditionally minded scholars for centuries.
  • Denmark Vesey
    Denmark Vesey Denmark Vesey was an African-American leader of an attempted slave insurrection in 1822. After many years as a slave, he won ,500 in a lottery. Vesey used this money to purchase his freedom. He used his intelligence, energy, and luck to acquire considerable wealth and influence in South Carolina. All of these factors helped lead to the largest attempted slave revolt in American history. David Robertson\'s book Denmark Vesey outlines his life as a slave, to his freedom, to his exe
  • The Social Realities of Rock ?n? Roll?s Birth and
    The Social Realities of Rock ?n? Roll?s Birth and the Teenager Research Proposal: The Social Realities of Rock ‘n\' Roll\'s Birth and the Teenager The story of the birth of rock ‘n\' roll has a mythical quality to it. It speaks of racial barriers bridged through the fusion of Afro-American musical styles with white popular music in 1950s America. Not only did white record producers and radio disc jockeys market Afro-American artists, but white artists began to cover their songs, as well as i
  • Historians Views On Bismark
    Historians Views On Bismark Introduction Hamerow begins his introduction with a defense of the theory that history is determined by the great people of society or The Great Man Theory of history. He goes on to say that "They are the makers of the world in which we live. Otto Von Bismarck belongs in this Company." The controversies surrounding his life still go on between historians today. He is portrayed as a destroyer of liberty and also as a compromiser of liberalism. Some see Bismarck as tryi
  • How Far Did The Policies Of Ol
    How Far Did The Policies Of Ol How far did the policies of Olivares represent realistic solutions to the problems of Spain? Introduction ‘The view is rapidly gaining currency that not only did Olivares\' policies for Spain and its empire not differ markedly from those of earlier Spanish statesmen, but that by and large the results of his manifold endeavours were both few and modest.\' This understanding of the historiography of Olivares\' effectiveness from Israel, makes Olivares look unorigin
  • Hindu Nationalism
    Hindu Nationalism Struggle Between Hindu and Secular Nationalisms in India India holds a prominent place in the history of imperialism and decolonization, making recent events in this country of nearly one billion especially important to the current day citizen. India also faces problems associated with accommodating religion and diversity within a large federal republic, making their experience important for Americans concerned with these issues. India faces growing action of governing which in
  • Progressive Historians
    Progressive Historians One must decide the meaning of "progressive historiography." It can mean either the history written by "progressive historians," or it can mean history written by historians of the Progressive era of American history and shortly after. The focus that was chosen for this paper is more in keeping with the latter interpretation, if for no other reason than it provides a useful compare-and-contrast "control" literature. The caveat is this: the focus of this report is on the pr
  • The Objectivity of History
    The Objectivity of History The issues that are raised in this source by Marc Trachtenberg are is whether or not objectivity is still a relevant idea, and if it is not then is history in fact dying. Keith Jenkins What is History?, Carl Beckers What are Historical Facts? and Richard Evans In Defence of History will be used to discuss and examine these issues. Marc Trachtenberg is questioning if objectivity is possible and desirable in todays society, and this is a question that many hist
  • The Importance of Bias in History
    The Importance of Bias in History Bias plays a weighty role in history and in historiography and without it the study of history would not be where it is today One- sidedness lies at the heart of history1. In saying this however bias distorts the truth, creates a preset agenda, can create untrue facts and destroys the role of history in the development of political institutions and decisions. Bias does however play a small advantageous role in history, it allows for historians to study the p