The Spanish Debate On The Americas Essay

This essay has a total of 911 words and 10 pages.

The Spanish Debate On The Americas


Juan Gines de Sepulveda, Bartolome de las Casas, and

Francisco de Vitoria arguments pertaining to the settlement and

colonization of the native people of America, while presented in

different manors, are all the same. All three Spaniards believed

that the barbarians had to accept the rule of the Spanish because

the Spanish were mentally superior, and divine and natural laws

gave the Spanish the right to conquer and enslave the native

people of America.

The foundation for Spanish conquests was their

interpretation of the bible. Ironically, it was the teachings of

the bible they were all trying to bring to the newly found

infidels. Sepulveda stated that the Spanish conquests were

sanctioned in divine law itself, for it was written in the Book

of Proverbs that "'He who is stupid will serve the wise man.'"

In propositions one and two, Bartolome de las Casas stated that

he believed that Jesus Christ had the authority and the power of

God himself over all men in the world, especially those who had

never heard the tidings of Christ nor of His faith. Las Casas

also stated in his second proposition that St. Peter and his

successors(that being missionaries located in the New World) had

the duty by the injunctions of God to teach the gospel and faith

of Jesus Christ to all men throughout the world. What is

interesting is that Las Casas thought that it was "unlikely that

anyone [would] resist the preaching of the gospel and the

Christian doctrine..." While being a bishop and a Dominican

missionary in the New World, he had the task of spreading the

holy faith, expanding the area covered by the teachings of the

universal Church(that being the Christian religion), and the

improvement of the natives' souls as his ultimate goal. As

stated in proposition ten however, the Indians sovereignty and

dignity and royal pre-eminence should not, in his belief

disappear either in fact or in right. "The only exceptions are

those infidels who maliciously obstruct the preaching of the

gospel... ." In proposition eleven though, he continues by

contradicting himself by saying that "He who persistently defends

it[that being the preaching of the missionaries] will fall into

formal heresy." Sepulveda also thought that if infidels

rejected the rule of Christianity, it could be imposed upon them

by force of arms. Sepulveda's justification for the use of force

was, after all, justified according to natural law, and that just

and natural noble people should rule over men who are not

"superior". War against the barbarians, according to Sepulveda,

was justified because of their paganism and also because of their

abominable licentiousness. Sepulveda and Las Casas both thought

that under no circumstances should the Indians be governed under

their own rules. The Spaniards took the initiative by

establishing several municipalities, which where governed by

local nobles. The single fact alone that "no one individual owns

anything,..." was enough for the Spaniards to establish a formal

overseas administration for the infidels. Las Casas states "[we]

are obliged by divine law to establish a government and

administration over the native peoples of the Indies..."

Sepulveda thought that those who were 'dim-witted' and mentally

lazy, although they may be physically strong are by nature

Continues for 5 more pages >>




  • A Comparison of Early American Texts
    A Comparison of Early American Texts A Comparison of Early American Texts When the Europeans first came to the Americas in the late 15th - early 16th century, they brought with them a distinctive style of literature that was a complete contrast to the Native Americans’ who inhabited the land. The Europeans’ system of literature was based on writing, which was a technique unheard of by the Native Americans, whose system of literature was based on oral traditions since they did not use alphabetic
  • Comparison of Empires
    Comparison of Empires Comparison of Empires Throughout the colonization of the New World, many different countries took place in the shaping of early America. The primary countries, Spain, France, and England, although all from the same continent, implemented many different plans and ideas for the development of their colonies. Contrasting cultures, languages, and governments all impacted the distinct ruling of the colonies. These policies placed restrictions on the all aspects of life including
  • The Voyage to the New World
    The Voyage to the New World The Voyage to the New World First of all, King Ferdinand of Aragon and Queen Isabella of Castille got married in 1464. The main reason that they got married was to unite their kingdoms into Spain. The king and queen were Roman Catholic, so they gave power to certain people to convert non-Catholics to Catholicism. In 1482, the Roman Catholic monarchs renew the reconquista, the military crusade ordered to conquer the remaining Muslim state in Iberia, Granada. In 1492,
  • Columbus
    columbus In 1492, an event took place that would change forever the way the world is viewed, and the way people viewed themselves. When Columbus set foot on that Caribbean island on an August morning over five hundred years ago, he set in motion one of the greatest migrations the world has ever seen. Two separate and distinct worlds met that day, even though both had populated their separate continents. One world, the old world, was made up of Europeans looking for fame and fortune, not necessa
  • Columbus the indians and the human progress
    columbus the indians and the human progress Spain, being recently unified, wanted spices and gold. The gold to them could purchase anything. So they offered Christopher Columbus ten percent of the profit, if he would bring back gold and spices. Christopher Columbus was sent to Asia with three ships: the Nina, the Pinta, and the Santa Maria. Columbus sailed for thirty-three days not sighting land. It wasn’t until early October of 1492 that he and his crew finally landed. He supposedly was the fi
  • Columbus
    columbus In 1492, an event took place that would change forever the way the world is viewed, and the way people viewed themselves. When Columbus set foot on that Caribbean island on an August morning over five hundred years ago, he set in motion one of the greatest migrations the world has ever seen. Two separate and distinct worlds met that day, even though both had populated their separate continents. One world, the old world, was made up of Europeans looking for fame and fortune, not necessa
  • The Devastation of the Indies
    The Devastation of the Indies The discovery and conquest of American Indians inspired efforts to develop an ideology that could justify why they needed to enslave the Indians. The Spanish monarch wanted an ideal empire. "A universal empire, of which all their subjects were but servants. Charles V remained for them the dominus mundi, the legitimate and God-ordained lord of the world." (Weckmann, The Transit of Civilization, 23) Gold and religious conversion was the two most important inspiration
  • Why Learn History
    Why Learn History Why Learn this History Stuff Anyway? As a high school student I was always annoyed by students who would ask: Why do we have to learn this stuff [history] anyway? We learn history so we don\'t repeat our mistakes. This is the common answer that my teachers, my father, and just about any other adult would give. This answer made perfect sense to me then, and I easily accepted it. In high school, students learn about the Nazi-Holocaust, and rightfully so. Information abounds rega
  • The Zen Of Zinn
    The Zen Of Zinn Dr. Howard Zinn\'s A People\'s History of the United States might be better titled A Proletarian\'s History of the United States. In the first three chapters Zinn looks at not only the history of the conquerors, rulers, and leaders; but also the history of the enslaved, the oppressed, and the led. Like any American History book covering the time period of 1492 until the early 1760\'s, A People\'s History tells the story of the "discovery" of America, early colonization by Europea
  • The Spanish Debate On The Americas
    The Spanish Debate On The Americas Juan Gines de Sepulveda, Bartolome de las Casas, and Francisco de Vitoria arguments pertaining to the settlement and colonization of the native people of America, while presented in different manors, are all the same. All three Spaniards believed that the barbarians had to accept the rule of the Spanish because the Spanish were mentally superior, and divine and natural laws gave the Spanish the right to conquer and enslave the native people of America. The foun
  • Las Casas Short Account Of The Destruction Of The
    Las Casas Short Account Of The Destruction Of The Indies Bartolome\' De Las Casas stated that "those who have traveled to this part of the world pretending to be Christians have uprooted these pitiful peoples and wiped them from the face of the earth (Las Casas, 12). After reading the horrific accounts of what has occurred to those "unassuming, long suffering, unassertive and submissive" peoples of the Indies that "are with out without malice or guile, and are utterly faithful and obedient both
  • The Spanish Debate On The Americas
    The Spanish Debate On The Americas Juan Gines de Sepulveda, Bartolome de las Casas, and Francisco de Vitoria arguments pertaining to the settlement and colonization of the native people of America, while presented in different manors, are all the same. All three Spaniards believed that the barbarians had to accept the rule of the Spanish because the Spanish were mentally superior, and divine and natural laws gave the Spanish the right to conquer and enslave the native people of America. The foun
  • Christianity
    Christianity Christianity Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all things that I have commanded you; and lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the age. 1 A simple directive spoken by God himself through Jesus Christ in the Sermon at the Mount, this Great Commission has impacted a countless number of lives throughout the years. The command given by Jesus at that time was actu
  • Zinns A Peoples History Of The United States: The
    Zinns A Peoples History Of The United States: The Oppressed Zinn\'s A People\'s History of the United States: The Oppressed Dr. Howard Zinn\'s A People\'s History of the United States might be better titled A Proletarian\'s History of the United States. In the first three chapters Zinn looks at not only the history of the conquerors, rulers, and leaders; but also the history of the enslaved, the oppressed, and the led. Like any American History book covering the time period of 1492 until the ear
  • The Zen Of Zinn
    The Zen Of Zinn Dr. Howard Zinn\'s A People\'s History of the United States might be better titled A Proletarian\'s History of the United States. In the first three chapters Zinn looks at not only the history of the conquerors, rulers, and leaders; but also the history of the enslaved, the oppressed, and the led. Like any American History book covering the time period of 1492 until the early 1760\'s, A People\'s History tells the story of the "discovery" of America, early colonization by Europea
  • The Age of Reformation
    The Age of Reformation The Age of Reformation The Age of Reformation - religious revolution in Western Europe in the 16th cent. Beginning as a reform movement within the Roman Catholic Church, the Reformation ultimately led to freedom of dissent. The preparation for the movement was long and there had been earlier calls for reform, e.g., by John WYCLIF and John HUSS. Desire for change within the church was increased by the RENAISSANCE, with its study of ancient texts and emphasis on the individu
  • Las Casas' Short Account of the Destruction of the
    Las Casas\' Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies Bartolome’ De Las Casas stated that “those who have traveled to this part of the world pretending to be Christians have uprooted these pitiful peoples and wiped them from the face of the earth (Las Casas, 12). After reading the horrific accounts of what has occurred to those “unassuming, long suffering, unassertive and submissive” peoples of the Indies that “are with out without malice or guile, and are utterly faithful and obedient both
  • Explain what Columbus expected to find in the Indi
    explain what Columbus expected to find in the Indies, how his reports reflected these findings Although the journals and diaries, in which Christopher Columbus is said to have recorded his discoveries, have long been lost to us and the ones that remain are not the originals, these works may not tell the whole story, or even possibly the truth of his discoveries. This essay will endeavor to explain what Columbus expected to find in the Indies, how his reports reflected these findings and the dece